Human rights groups are lining up to pressure Congress not to authorize the provision of U.S. military aid to the Central Asian country of Uzbekistan, even though such assistance could prove crucial to getting supplies into and out of Afghanistan.
With the Obama administration weighing whether to request a waiver that would allow military aid to Uzbekistan for the first time since 2005, the groups recently sent a letter to members of the Senate pleading with them to oppose any such move, saying, “Uzbekistan’s status as a strategic partner to the United States should not be allowed to eclipse concerns about its appalling human rights record.”
The issue of military aid to Uzbekistan is a complicated one, but goes to the heart of the U.S.-led military campaign in Afghanistan. Uzbekistan has been prohibited from receiving military aid since government security forces there massacred demonstrators six years ago, and the authoritarian state has carried out a host of human rights abuses since that time.1
From an article published in last weeks’ Washington Post.
“For the US to lift its restrictions now would be an enormous gift to one of the most repressive governments in Central Asia.
In the midst of the Arab Spring, the administration should have learned that downplaying human rights with abusive allies is not only harmful for the population affected, but damages the United States’ interests and reputation over the long-term.”2
said Hugh Williamson, Europe and Central Asia director at Human Rights Watch.
Click here to read the full report.
Former British Ambassador to Uzbekistan (2002–2004), Craig Murray, who resigned his position because he found “Western support for the dictatorial Karimov regime unconscionable”, says that Obama’s request is yet further evidence that the war in Afghanistan is already lost:
Unfortunately, by promoting evil dictatorship in Central Asia, the United States and NATO are not advancing their own long term interests. Like Mubarak, Karimov is passing his sell-by date. But all rational thinking is thrown out of the window as NATO concentrates on the war it is losing in Afghanistan. […]
They have lost this war so absolutely that they no longer have possession of the ground they started with. They cannot get out the way they went in, through Pakistan, as they would be attacked in the Bolan and Khyber passes, and along the entire route. So they have to leave through Uzbekistan. The Americans will do anything for Karimov, just as long as they get permission to slink out through his country. I hope as they go they look into the faces of the people whose continued enslavement buys their permission.
Click here to read more of Craig Murray’s blog.
1From an article entitled “Rights groups rally to oppose U.S. Aid to Uzbekistan” written by Jason Ukman, published in the Washington Post on September 15, 2011. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/checkpoint-washington/post/rights-groups-rally-to-oppose-us-aid-to-uzbekistan/2011/09/15/gIQANpoQUK_blog.html
2 From an article entitled “Uzbekistan: US Shouldn’t Green-Light Aid” posted by Human Rights Watch on September 7, 2011. http://www.hrw.org/news/2011/09/07/uzbekistan-us-shouldn-t-green-light-aid